We are always told that imitation is the best form of flattery, but not when it involves body parts being washed ashore on the River Thanes. DI Henley is just starting back to work in the field after some time off, and this is not what she thought her first day back would look like. She did not think that it would bring her back to the case that caused her to go off work and the the Jigsaw Man, Peter Olivier, would be making a reappearance in her life ever again. But someone is trying to get his attention and using his methods to do it and Henley and her team now have to find and put together the links before more bodies are found.
I love starting a new series and I feel like I have not read a police procedural book in a long time. I was not sure what to expect out of this book, as I have not read anything by Matheson before but I remember this book being all the rage a few years ago but I have not heard much about this series since. As this was the first book in a series, you always need to get a feel for the characters you are reading about. You understand that they have history before this book and you are seeing them as they are now, but I felt like there was a whole other book before this one as events that happened previously are referenced multiple times throughout the book especially at the beginning in a way that felt more like i had missed something major along the way. This makes this book read more like a second book in a series instead of a first one.It does get better with not feeling this way the farther you read into it, I was just put off a bit at the beginning because of this.
I enjoyed and appreciated how Matheson let the investigation(s) unfold in this book. Matheson showed that not every lead was going to be the one they needed or take them where the investigators thought it would lead. Investigations hit dead ends and a promising lead can lead to nothing or even something that they could use. I liked that Matheson understood circumstantial evidence and that this was not enough to charge a person and that they needed more.
While we did not get the first case that featured Olivier we certainly see the affects he has had on DI Henley. I think that Matheson did a good job showing some of the affect of PTSD as well as Henley's will and desire to just push through it all and do her job even to the detriment of her mental health and her family life. DI Henley is a complicated character at times, her desire her passion for the job is admirable but the toll it takes on her is not. It is interesting see the other side of the coin with the female officer and the Husband taking point of caring for their child and the resentment he feels towards her and her job for the time it take her away from the family. I think that Henley's home life is portrayed pretty accurately in this book and while I do not agree with all the decisions Hadley makes, I did like her as a character as she felt her portrayal was very real.
There are a few disturbing chapters, that are short, that are told from the killer and/or victim POV when they are doing the killing or being killed. They are not overly descriptive but Matheson does enough for someone to get the uncomfortable feelings about what is being done.
I did end up really enjoying this book even after a somewhat slow/confusing start of this book relying a bit too heavy on past events. However once you're in it you’re in it and the twists and turns keep coming till the end. I look forward to continuing on in the series.